Church Happiness VS Missional Faithfulness

by Rev. Mark E. Tidsworth, Founder and Team Leader

“They have treated the wound of my people carelessly, saying, ‘peace, peace,’ when there is no peace.” — Jeremiah 6:14

“Congregational leaders, clergy and laity alike, are seeking ways to end the complaint game. They are learning to make decisions based on their understanding of the congregation’s call to ministry or its core purpose, rather than according to an individual’s or group’s preferences.” — Gil Rendle in “The Illusion of Congregational Happiness.”

What are we really after here? What’s the goal of church anyway? What’s health mean for churches? How much are we looking to please people versus transform people? These are always relevant questions. 

How then do congregational leaders, clergy and laity, help congregations navigate their strokes and find their form? Gil Rendle writes a pithy article in an Alban Institute book on congregational happiness. He encourages congregations to consider their core values. Are we about keeping as many people as possible happy? Or are we about something larger and more significant? My experience with congregations is that most find themselves on a continuum somewhere between each of these questions. Pastors, church staff, and lay leadership teams play out their ministries on the same continuum. How happy or content does this group need to be in order to risk missional ministry? How much security and comfort are needed in this congregation in order to strengthen the capacity for change?

Ideally, our hope as Christian people who are heavily invested in Christian faith communities is that we can rise to higher purposes. Rendle encourages congregations to refocus priorities onto mission and calling. The false god of happiness needs to go. When congregational happiness is enshrined, God’s Holy Spirit is constrained, change is minimized or eliminated, and leadership energy is consumed internally rather than in external ministry. Our world needs more than a warm and fuzzy congregational float trip.

One way to refocus ourselves on mission rather than happiness is by paying attention to our questions. Problem/happiness questions are:

• Who wants what?

• How do we satisfy this person or that group?

• What should we do about a problem or complaint that displeases our members?

Instead, purposeful missional questions are:

• Who are we and who are we called to be?

• What are we called to do in this chapter of our congregational history?

• What are the goals and/or objectives that we set out to accomplish in our ministry?

• What are the appropriate strategies for our ministry, and how will we measure its attainment?

What happens when clergy and laity ask these kinds of questions and lead with purpose? The congregation finds an opportunity to define itself. Are we more about contentment with a pleasant group or more about missional ministry? I am hoping that the best in Christian churches will rise up and define itself in terms of faithfulness to the mission of God. We are about so much more than contentment. I am hoping that we can delay gratification now, serve strong and faithfully, finding contentment in a ministry well done and a world aware of God’s love.

Happiness or faithfulness? May God strengthen Christian faith communities with resolve to swim well.

Previous
Previous

What Happens If We Don’t Have a Child Protection Policy?

Next
Next

Why I am an Evangelist for Coaching